2
$\begingroup$

It would be a silly question. In a model, I have found the BGP (balanced growth path) for all key variables.

As expected, these variables are constant variables ;

$$\mu^{BGP}=\frac{\alpha+\rho+\pi}{\epsilon\left(1+\pi\right)^{2}}$$

All paramaters on the right hand side are exogeneous constant parameters. Let's say $\mu$ is a variable for technological progress level.

For another variable, let's say capital accumulation $k$,I find a constant growth rate which is ;

$$g_{k}=\frac{\alpha\left(\rho+\pi-\delta\left(\frac{1-\alpha}{\alpha}\right)\right)}{1-\alpha}$$

The parameters on the RHS are again exogenous parameters.

My question is : Is it possible to see the effect of the variable $\mu$ on the growth rate of capital $g_k$ ?

My way of doing seems to me a little bit weird. I firstly put

$$\rho=\mu^{BGP}\epsilon\left(1+\pi\right)^{2}-\alpha-\pi$$

and replace it in $g_k$. So, I have

$$g_{k}=\frac{\alpha\left(\mu^{BGP}\epsilon\left(1+\pi\right)^{2}-\alpha-\delta\left(\frac{1-\alpha}{\alpha}\right)\right)}{1-\alpha}$$

After, I say that technological progress level at BGP affects positevly the growth rate of capital.

Do you think that it is correct to say that ? Making this kind of comparative statics analysis ?

Or any other way to do it in a more appropriate way ?

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The approach is not correct, because $\mu^{BGP}$ is a result of underlying structural parameters. So to say "when $\mu^{BGP}$ increases..." immediately begs the question why it increases, which underlying parameter(s) has changed to cause such an increase... assume it was $\epsilon$ that decreased. But in this case $g_k$ is not affected at all, so you see that you cannot claim what you claim about $\mu^{BGP}$ affecting positively $g_k$.

What is meaningful to do is to perform comparative statics for the exogenous parameters, and record whether $\mu^{BGP}$ and $g_k$ move in the same or the opposite direction (or don't move) in each case. It may not be a causal link, but co-movement is also a useful result, and testable.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.