How does one solve utility maximization of perfect substitutes using Lagrangian function?

Consider the problem $$\max_{x,y} ax +by $$

subject to the constraint that

$$px + qy \leq I$$

where $a,b,p,q,I>0$.

Note problem statement are subject to the standard implicit assumptions that consumption cannot be negative.


1 Answer 1


Your Lagrangian would be $$L = (ax+by)+\lambda (I−p_x x−p_y y) +\mu_x(x−0)+\mu_y(y-0),$$ where the final two terms represent the restriction that $x,y\geq0$.

You then arrive at conditions $$\frac{\partial L}{\partial x}= a -\lambda p_x +\mu_x=0$$ $$\frac{\partial L}{\partial y}= b -\lambda p_y +\mu_y=0$$ $$I=p_x x+p_y y$$ and complementary slackness conditions $$\mu_x x =0 , \quad \mu_y y =0.$$

You then consider many different cases: $(\mu_x>0,x=0,\mu_y=0,y>0),(\mu_x=0,x>0,\mu_y=0,y>0), (\mu_x=0,x=0,\mu_y=0,y>0), ....$ and for each of them you look at your conditions:

Suppose $(\mu_x>0,x=0,\mu_y=0,y>0)$. Then, $$a -\lambda p_x +\mu_x=0 \Rightarrow a -\lambda p_x <0$$ $$b -\lambda p_y +\mu_y=b -\lambda p_y=0$$ $$\Rightarrow a -\frac{b}{p_y} p_x <0 \iff \frac{a}{p_x} <\frac{b}{p_y}$$ This condition can be checked as $a,b,p_x,p_y$ are given. If it does not hold, $x=0,y>0$ cannot be the solution. If it does hold, it means that the utility per dollar is higher for good $y$ and all money should be spend on $y$ (which $x=0,y>0$ and the budget constraint imply).

You have to check all the cases, but you will arrive at a solution of the above form.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.