3
$\begingroup$

We are in an Insurance Adverse Selection. Assume that consumers differ in their own risk $\pi_i$ distributed on the interval $[\underline \pi, \bar\pi ]=[0, 0.5] $. CDF is as follows $F(\pi)= 2\pi^2 + \pi.$ where $\pi$ is private information and Loss (denoted as L) is equal to $1$ for all consumers. Consider the risk-neutral, competitive insurance companies which offer full insurance at price $p$. The consumers’ utility function is $U(w)=\sqrt{w}$ and initial wealth $w_0 = 5$ are equal for all consumers.

The problem asks for $h(p)$. With which price $p$ only the consumer with $\pi_i = 0.5$ will buy the insurance? And then to find equilibrium price $p^*.$

Now to find $h(p)=\frac{u(w)-u(w-p)}{u(w)-u(w-L)}$ and $p^*=\frac{\int_{h(p^*)}^{\pi}\pi dF(\pi)}{1 − F(h(p^∗)) }L$

For the first part: $h(p)=\frac{u(w)-u(w-p)}{u(w)-u(w-L)}=\frac{\sqrt{5}-\sqrt{5-p}}{\sqrt{5}-2}$. The consumer with $\pi_i=0.5$ will buy the insurance if $\frac{\sqrt{5}-\sqrt{5-p}}{\sqrt{5}-2}\leq 0.5$ (after some math) we find $p=0.5$, only consumer with $\pi_i=0.5$ buys.

For the equilibrium part:

$p^*=\frac{\int_{h(p^*)}^{0.5}\pi dF(\pi)}{1 − F(h(p^∗)) }=\frac{\frac{7}{9}-1/2(h(p^*))^4-1/3(h(p^*))^3}{1-2(h(p^*))^2-h(p^*)}$

Combining both: $h(p^*)\frac{\sqrt{5}-\sqrt{5-p^*}}{\sqrt{5}-2}$ and considering $p^*=0.5$

$h(p^*)=0.5 \rightarrow$ $p^*=E[\pi_i|\pi_i\geq h(p^*)]$ holds when $p^*=0.5$ thus it is an equilibrium. Only those with $\pi_i=0.5$ buys

$\endgroup$
0

1 Answer 1

2
$\begingroup$

Your derivation looks ok, but maybe a bit too complicated. Notice that if there is perfect competition in the insurance market and if firms only sell to the $\pi_i = 0.5$ type then expected profits (per contract) is zero and equals: $$ p - 0.5 L = 0 $$ This immediately gives $p = 0.5$ if $L = 1$.

Also, your incentive constraint is somewhat off as: $$ \frac{\sqrt{5} - \sqrt{5 - 0.5}}{\sqrt{5} - 2} = 0.486079 $$ which is not exactly equal to 0.5

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ Thank you for your imput. Yeah, I redid it again and got something similar. $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 5, 2021 at 20:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.