7
$\begingroup$

I need to know the difference between Social Choice, Public Choice and collective decision-making. Also, Is public choice, social choice the same as collective choice? Thank you

$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

Social choice theory or social choice is a theoretical framework for analysis of combining individual opinions, preferences, interests, or welfares to reach a collective decision or social welfare in some sense.1

A social choice is related to a collective decision. Many different opinions, preferences and interests are taken into account to form a decision which is acceptable by everyone who is involved. Opinions, preferences and interests don't just have a personal background, but a social one, too. The society around you influences your thinking and doing by socializing. Hence the name: Social choice theory.

Group decision-making (also known as collaborative decision-making) is a situation faced when individuals collectively make a choice from the alternatives before them. The decision is then no longer attributable to any single individual who is a member of the group.2

Collective decision-making refers to a group of people who are committed to make a decision. Collective means that the decision isn't made upon the ideas of one person but of several. Responsibility is shared among these people. One alone can't be held responsible for the decision as several people agreed to it.

A. What is Public Choice? Public choice is the study of political decision making.

i. It attempts to understand how public policies come to be adopted using economic models of the impacts of policies on individuals,

ii. and models of individual political behavior under a variety of political institutions.

iii. It tends to use rational choice models to do so, which is largely what distinguishes it from mainstream and classical political economy.3

[...] iii. (Roughly speaking, public choice, and/or rational politics, is the application of economic models of human action to politics.)

The theory of Public choice believes that every politician is rational and economically (self-)interested. The goal of Public choice is to analyze and predict the behaviour of politicians and bureaucrats - analyzing their public choice.

Social choice theory and group decision-making are somewhat related to each other. However, a social choice doesn't need to be made by several people, it just has to represent several people. By considering a lot of interests and preferences, one or more make a decision to achieve the best.

Public choice is more like a field of research. Hence, it's related to both Social choice and group decision-making. As it's the application of economic models of human action to politics, you research the advantages and disadvantages of doing public decisions.

Long story short: Social choices and group decision-making are actions, Public choice is a field of study which researches political behaviour out of a economic view. All three are related to each other but still are independent approaches for making a decision.


$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Collective decision-making is not really a term used by economists.

Collective choice theory = social choice theory (SCT). (Sen's 1970 book was titled Collective Choice and Social Welfare, but I think social choice theory is now the more standard term.)


Social choice theory (SCT) is the study of what social welfare is and of how a rational society should act, in order to maximize social welfare.

Public choice (PC) recognizes that societies are not "rational" and do not seek to maximize "social welfare" (whatever that is). Instead, societies are composed of self-interested actors (voters, politicians, bureaucrats, businessman, etc.). PC is thus the study of how a society with self-interested actors actually acts.

One possible (if simplistic) characterization of the difference between SCT and PC may thus be the good ol' positive-normative dichotomy: SCT studies how society should act, while PC studies how society actually does act.


Amartya Sen on SCT in the New Palgrave Dictionary:

Social choice theory, pioneered in its modern form by Arrow (1951), is concerned with the relation between individuals and the society. In particular, it deals with the aggregation of individual interests, or judgements, or well-beings, into some aggregate notion of social welfare, social judgement or social choice.

SCT examines the rational basis for answering these questions:

  1. Society consists of Ann and Bob. Society must choose between alternative $x$ and alternative $y$. Ann prefers $x$ to $y$ while Bob prefers $y$ to $x$. Which should society choose?

  2. 90% of the population will benefit greatly from a nuclear plant. The remaining 10% will die a horrible death. Should society build a nuclear plant?

Key figures in SCT are Kenneth Arrow and Amartya Sen.


Gordon Tullock on PC in the New Palgrave Dictionary:

We do not expect businessmen to devote a great deal of time and attention to maximizing the public interest. We assume that, although they will of course make some sacrifices to help the poor and advance the public welfare, basically they are concerned with benefiting themselves. Traditionally economists did not take the same attitude towards government officials, but public choice theory does.

PC studies such questions:

  1. In a democracy, 40% of the population are farmers while 30% are factory workers. What sort of trade policies are likely to be enacted?

  2. Why are bridges to nowhere built, while potholes on busy roads left unrepaired?

Key figures in PC are James M. Buchanan and Gordon Tullock.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.