5
$\begingroup$

This is question about Kaplan and Menzio's shopping time model.

Pages 7,8: Unemployed search once or twice (for a seller).

  • $\psi_u$:probability of searching twice, searching once with prob $1-\psi_u$
  • $\nu$ is the probability of finding a seller.
  • Searches are independent. An unemployed who searches twice, hence has the probability of finding two sellers of $\nu^2$.

Now here's the problem, on page 10, they look at it from a seller's point of view. Conditional of the seller of being matched with a buyer, what is the probability of the buyer being matched with another seller?

$$ Prob(\text{being matched second seller} | \text{being matched with first seller}) = \frac{Prob(\text{being matched with first and second seller})}{Prob(\text{being matched with first seller})} \\ = \frac{\text{search twice and find both times}}{\text{search once and find a seller or search twice and find one or two sellers }} \\ = \frac{\psi_u\nu^2}{((1-\psi_u) * \nu) + (\psi_u)*(\nu + \nu)}\\ = \frac{\psi_u\nu}{1+\psi_u}\\ $$

However, what they get is

$$ \frac{2\psi_u\nu}{1+\psi_u}$$

They compute some "intermediate probabilities" on page 8, but I don't see how they help get their result. How does one get their result?

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

The first / second seller terminology can be confusing here (does it relate to time or to conditionality?). It's safer to focus on a particular seller.

Let the probability that a buyer finds a particular seller, $s$, via single search be $\nu_s$. The probability that a buyer is matched with $s$ and (either before or after) another seller is then (assuming that $\nu_s$ is small so that the probability of finding $s$ twice in at most 2 searches can be ignored):

$$\psi_u(\nu_s\nu+\nu\nu_s)= 2\psi_u\nu_s\nu$$

The probability that a buyer is matched with $s$ via either a single or a double search is (again ignoring the probability, given a double search, of finding $s$ twice):

$$(1-\psi_u)\nu_s + \psi_u(\nu_s + \nu_s)=\nu_s(1+\psi_u)$$

The conditional probability of a buyer being matched with $s$ and another seller, conditional on $s$ being matched with that buyer, is therefore:

$$\frac{2\psi_u\nu_s\nu}{\nu_s(1+\psi_u)}=\frac{2\psi_u\nu}{1+\psi_u}$$

But the latter formula does not depend on $\nu_s$. Hence the same formula applies to any seller.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

Here's another way, using the same notation as Adam, to get to the same result:

$$P(\text{another match | being matched}) = P(\text{searching twice | being matched})\cdot P(\text{another match | searching twice}) $$

Now,

$$P(\text{searching twice | being matched}) = \frac{P(\text{searching twice and being matched})}{P(\text{being matched})} \\ = \frac{\psi_u 2 \nu_s}{(1+\psi_u)\nu_s} $$

$$P(\text{another match | searching twice}) = \frac{P(\text{another match and searching twice})}{P(\text{searching twice})} \\ = \frac{\psi_u \nu}{\psi_u} $$

So,

$$P(\text{another match | being matched}) = \frac{\psi_u 2 \nu_s}{(1+\psi_u)\nu_s}\frac{\psi_u \nu}{\psi_u} = \frac{2\psi_u\nu}{(1+\psi_u)}$$

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.